In Praise of Half-Baked Ideas

by Keith Monaghan

A Twitter Experiment Dies A Quick (And Deserved) Death

It was called “I Should Know That! The Twitter Trivia Game“. And it was an utter and miserable failure.

The idea: tweet witty trivia questions, followers tweet back answers, a winner is declared, everyone has fun!

Popularity, speaking engagements, a book deal, and my own show on NPR were sure to follow.

The reality: mind-scrambling chaos and indifference.

Answers from a mere 17 followers became impossible to manage. Who was first? That guy? No, wait, her! Too many tweets! Agh!

In short, it was not scalable. Duh.

But now I know.

It could have been a project that was developed over weeks or months, every aspect thought out, every “what if” question asked and exhaustively answered. And it probably would have still failed.

In a fraction of that time I quickly discovered a few things:

  • Each daily quiz was a huge time-suck of research and administration.
  • Sometimes simple rules aren’t enough.
  • It was probably a dumb idea.

But that’s the beauty of putting your half-baked ideas out there, isn’t it? Rapid deployment can lead to rapid enlightenment. In the case of “I Should Know That!” the insight was that I didn’t want to pursue it. End of story. Case closed.

In fact, there’s a certain school of thought that says you should release your incomplete product or service into the wild and let customers dictate what it should be. You’ll learn a heck of a lot about said product and what you’re trying to achieve, possibly saving a lot of time, effort, and money in the process. Whether you agree with them or not is beside the point.

So, my idea of a twitter-based trivia game is yours for the taking. Just remember me if it becomes a runaway success. I’m the guy who screwed it up the first time.

See also:

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: